5 Bedroom Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

At Island Real Estate, we have vacation rental properties located in Eleuthera’s most sought after areas, from The Current and Governor’s Harbour to Whale Point and Spanish Wells. In particular, our 5 bedroom rentals offer some of the most luxurious Eleuthera cottages on the island, ensuring you and your guests experience the best of Eleuthera’s hospitality. Peruse our exclusive selection of Eleuthera 5 bedroom vacation rentals by clicking through the properties below!

Book our Eleuthera cottages today!


Unable to find any listings.

Sort by
Excluding taxes & fees
{[property.price | currency]}
Including Taxes & Fees
{[property.total | currency]}
Rates Starting From
{[property.price_data.daily | currency]}



Bedrooms: {[property.bedrooms_number]} / Bathrooms: {[property.bathrooms_number]} / Sleeps: {[property.max_occupants]}

Eleuthera Cottages with Luxe Features

Between their unbeatable locations, serene views, and expansive floor plans, you’ll find that our 5 bedroom Eleuthera cottages for rent will leave you wanting for nothing during your time on the island.

Many of our properties enjoy beachfront views and immediate access to Eleuthera’s unique, distinctly hued pink sand beaches, as well as locations within just a short distance of the bay.

Soak up the ambiance of island breezes and waves that stretch out across the horizon from the vantage point of the outdoor lounge spaces that our rentals offer, equipped with chaise lounges, hammocks, swaying palm trees, and more.

In some of our Eleuthera cottages, you and your guests can even use complimentary kayaks and other private amenities for downtime recreation in between exploring the island. Push off from the private beach and begin your next adventure!

Inside, spacious living rooms with open layouts provide a relaxed gathering place for you and your guests to enjoy each other’s company or a show on the high end flat screen television.

Huge yet inviting, the bedrooms in our properties function as your own private haven after hours of fun and excitement in the sun and on the sand. Rest your head on soft linens and comfy beds while drifting off to the sound of the tide lapping on the shore. Some bedrooms even offer televisions or stereos for you to enjoy.

Immaculate bathrooms make the most ordinary parts of your day into a spa-like experience.

Full kitchens give you and your guests the option of dining in if you choose, outfitted with a full range of appliances.

Regardless of how you spend your time on the island, you can always come home to the comfort of your vacation rental.

Indulge Your Taste Buds at Eleuthera Restaurants

Between the pink sand beaches, opportunities to get out on the water and beautiful vantage points, Eleuthera is sure to be a vacation destination that inspires the senses. When you’re looking to make the most of hiking, beach hopping, sailing, and snorkeling, Eleuthera is a destination that never disappoints. Include your taste buds on the adventure when it comes to a full island experience by making your way to a few of these amazing restaurant stops while you’re here! While it certainly doesn’t cover the full list, it’s a great start when it comes to palate-pleasing experiences in Eleuthera.

Daddy Joe’s Restaurant

Known for it’s cozy and casual ambiance, Daddy Joe’s Restaurant is located on Queens Highway and is a wonderful place to stop for an authentic and savory Bahamian meal. Loved by locals and visitors alike, Daddy Joe’s Restaurant is a fun and friendly establishment where guests can enjoy everything from curry shrimp and jasmine rice to fresh-caught fare of the day. Daddy Joe’s Restaurant sits on the remote north end of the island and provides the perfect excuse to enjoy an off the beaten path adventure with a savory reward at the end. No matter what you order, be sure to pair it with a delicious red or hand-crafted cocktail that’s sure to inspire!

Buccaneer Club Restaurant and Bar

Serving up breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily, the Buccaneer Club Restaurant and Bar is a one-stop-shop for all things delicious when you’re traveling to Eleuthera with family. This culinary stop is open daily from 7:00 am until 9:00 pm and invites those with a passion for the perfect cocktail, wine or beer selection to come and enjoy Happy Hour every Tuesday through Saturday from 4:00 pm until 6:00 pm.

The menu at Buccaneer Club Restaurant and Bar features a variety of options that range from conch chowder and chicken wings to burgers, seafood, and salad. A full kids menu makes this an easy stop when you’re looking to feed picky eaters. Buccaneer Club Restaurant and Bar also cater to vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free guests upon request. No matter what you decide to enjoy, be sure to save room for a homemade dessert that’s cooked up daily and is always a fun surprise! If you’re part of the Buccaneer breakfast crowd, enjoy everything from pancakes and eggs to omelets and breakfast sandwiches to start your day right. Those who swing by for lunch will enjoy a selection of mahi-mahi, grouper fingers and sweet and sour chicken to get the taste buds tingling. This restaurant is definitely a place to visit when you book a stay in our Eleuthera cottages!

Escape to the Caribbean with our Eleuthera Cottages Today!

To learn more about the wonders that are waiting for you in the Caribbean, call or email our team of representatives today and ask about booking your lodgings in one of our lovely vacation rental properties!